What makes a man?

CW: This post discusses mental health and sexism. Reader discretion is advised.

Unless you’ve been living under a rock online, you’ll have seen the discussions going on about Harry Styles and his, in my opinion, gorgeous photoshoot and interview with Vogue.

The pictures entail him in various feminine and androgynous clothing, most notably, a photograph wearing a black blazer with a blue ruffled dress. If anyone doesn’t know what Harry Styles is like, he is very much the type of person that is expressive with his style, particularly in quite an androgynous way, reminiscent of David Bowie and the New Romantic subculture of the 1980s.

But, as you can imagine, these photos have caused a bit of a stir, particularly from right-wing conservatives such as Candice Owens. Those who are on social media will have seen her tweet, calling to ‘bring back manly men’ and claiming the West is being subject to the feminization of its men, undermining masculinity in the process.

As you know, I have a very different take on that of Ms. Owens’. Being brought up by 80s Rockers and New Romantics, while I grew up with the generalised notions of masculinity and femininity, being around expressive, artsy types and my feminist parents, the breaking of gender stereotypes isn’t something new to me.

Personally, what I like about people like Harry Styles is that he just doesn’t care what others think of him for what he wears. What we wear is a form of expression, and in the last few years particularly, are more men, especially young men, challenging those notions of ‘Only men can wear this’ and ‘Only women can wear that.’ etc. Like women challenged the notions that only men could and should wear trousers, the same is now happening with men.

As well, this is not just about men and women. As we know, gender is a spectrum through trans and non-binary awareness, as well as countless history on genders outside the binary in Indigenous cultures, such as Two-Spirit people in numerous Native American tribes. Though gender identity, sexual orientation and various expression with one’s clothes aren’t inherently linked, like some would like to believe, everyone’s expression is unique to them.

Harry Styles is a cisgender (someone who’s gender identity matches with their birth sex) man, who is one of many men in the limelight challenging these gender archetypes. While many have been doing this for years, the media hasn’t paid much attention, or subjected them to ridicule, until someone in Styles’ position (particularly if they’re white, because systemic racism) does the same. So, I’m happy that he’s using his platform to do this.

Some have taken to ridicule and anger, because a man has worn a dress. In the midst of a pandemic, political and civil unrest and climate change, this is where the anger is directed: a man wearing a dress. Amongst teasing and holier-than-thou statements, comes the age-old chestnut: ‘He’s not a real man!’

WHAT MAKES A ‘REAL’ MAN?

The last time I checked, all mean are real, lest they be formed in fiction. But it’s the concept of what ‘real’ masculinity is, that is the source of all this discussion.

We have often been taught that to be a man, you have to be tall, big, rough and tough, showing little outward emotion and to like nothing perceived as ‘feminine’. Now while there are men like that (and there’s nothing wrong with that) obviously, not every man is like this. Just as not all women are long haired, blonde, who love pink and go shoe shopping.

We see reactions, particularly online, to men showing their feelings, getting mental health support, or wearing clothes considered feminine, being derided with various insults and slurs.

If you wear pink you must be gay. If they cry, they’re a ‘sissy’. If they show their love for family, openly state they can’t wait to be a Dad, or go to the doctor for a health concern, they’re ‘weak’. If they’re not earning more than a female partner, they’re ‘whipped’.

These are examples of what is known, as toxic masculinity. Preventing men from either expressing themselves, getting the help they need etc. because of a preconceived notion that this doesn’t make him a ‘real’ man.

Not only is this utter garbage, these derisions and pressures contribute to something truly terrible: The biggest killer in men under 50 is suicide. Not heart disease, cancer or road accidents (even though those are terrible as well and definitely shouldn’t be overlooked) but suicide.

Just that fact alone shows we have a massive problem in how we address masculinity. Thankfully, these are now being addressed, but not without its opposition.

Also, toxic femininity exists too. Primarily in the form of, ‘all women belong in the kitchen’, ‘you’re not a real woman if you don’t have children’ and ‘take her swimming on the first date’ just to name a few. And don’t even get me started on toxic behaviour towards trans and non-binary people. Toxic behaviour like this, even if it’s towards just one gender (in this context, men) will sooner or later affect everyone.

MY STUDY ON MASCULINITY

Back in university, I actually did a study on this. When I was 19, I did a research project on masculinity in film, and how it can affect perceptions of masculinity at the time of production and release, and vice versa.

I loved doing that study and researching, having quantitative and qualitative research done. These were in the form of surveying various men who would fill out a questionnaire and submit anonymously, along with interviewing a Professor in this field from a university in America.

This came up with some very interesting results (albeit I didn’t have the biggest group of data to analyse), especially for 2013, and have times changed since then! I can only imagine what my results would be now, especially if I had a larger group for data analysis.

QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

I tried get to as wide a range of data to analyse as possible. My gentlemen who filled out this questionnaire ranged from 18 – 85 in age, from students to IT consultants, retired, family, to then-active servicemen. They also ranged across various religions, nationality, ethnicity and social background.

Relating to my study, I studied two films with social commentaries on masculinity. One set and surrounding the military, which is known for being a hyper-masculine environment. The other, centring around a male character who was a cross-dresser and drag performer. My questions centred around the themes in the films.

Along with many being raised in traditional backgrounds, majority felt there was support towards the LGBTQ+ community and were happy about it. Most stated they were feminists and were fully on board with equality. As well, 45% of those surveyed felt there was more sexism towards men in recent years. (Don’t shoot the messenger, I’m just citing the results)

This last statement I found particularly interesting, with some citing first hand experiences of being harassed or bullied by the occasional individual claiming also to be feminist, purely on the grounds that they were men. Obviously, this isn’t right and no one should be treated like that. This affected, if not fuelled, their stances and support for equality, to treat everyone equally regardless of gender.

I finished off the questionnaire with this: What does being a man mean to you?

A GOOD PERSON

As well as answers that included protecting and providing for the family, the vast majority (98% approx.) answered the same thing:

Being a good person.

Not only did it surprise me the amount of times receiving the same answer in its short, blunt state, it made me incredibly happy to read it. While I can’t remember word for word, I remember a few of the answers in particular, stating that what are considered masculine traits didn’t matter to them, in fact deconstructing them altogether.

One in particular said (paraphrased): ‘It’s not about gender, it’s about being a good human being.

I couldn’t agree more. Regardless of what you wear, or whether you’re a man, a woman, cis, trans, non-binary, etc. that’s what it comes down to: being a good person.

That, to me, is the pinnacle of what being a man is.

*Images – vogue.com

If you like what I do and wish to support me, consider buying me a coffee or subscribing to my Patreon for exclusive erotica and writing classes.

9 thoughts on “What makes a man?

  1. Robert Bittner

    My def of being a good man starts with being a good human, a respectful citizen of the world. It requires accountability, ethics, and the awareness that conflicting personalities are a byproduct of natural variety, and thus never a true threat.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Great piece Violet, completely agree that there is nothing more important than just being a good person. I have and still feel toxic masculinity, I am short and skinny, with soft features which have lead me to question my masculinity. At 30 I now feel more comfort in who I am, but know it is a journey much more difficult for others than me.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Thank you 🙂 It definitely is a journey from a female perspective as well, feeling ‘I should be married with kids by now’ or that I should look or act a certain way etc. At the end of the day as long as you’re a good person, that’s all that matters. x

      Liked by 2 people

    2. David Mei

      Violet, I love your research. I remember the comments in the 70’s about Bowie. I was also raised in the era where men were gaged against John Wayne and Sean Connery. I’m learning that being a gentleman, my definition of a man, is being gentle, kind, and serving family, community, and the world. What this post made me ask:
      What is the feminine of Gentleman?
      Why does it matter?
      In the 21st century why are we still concerned about boxes like “Real Man”, or “Real Woman”?
      Shouldn’t we all strive to be good and do good?
      I love the way you make me think.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you David, that’s honestly put a massive smile on my face! 😀 My parents who were my age in the late 70s and 80s often tell me how much things have changed since when they were younger. My father was quite progressive for the time, having a openly gay friend in a group of straight guys and no one cared. Whereas on my Mum’s side, in her school if anyone was they would be ostracised and beaten, as well as the men who would go out every weekend ‘gay bashing’ as it was called D: I agree, we shouldn’t be concerned on trivial things that makes a ‘real’ man, woman, non-binary person etc. We should all strive to do and be good and better. xx

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Kindness and consideration are so important. I know good men who are gay, single, married etc. Their sexuality or religious beliefs have no bearing on whether they are good men. It’s their other attributes that matter. I have no time for “men” like Donald Trump! They are evil caricatures of men.
    Good post!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Michael 🙂 I completely agree, DJT is the epitome of everything that is wrong with the world. His lack of humanity and compassion is beyond astounding. Just when you think he can’t go any lower, he does. Being a good person is at the forefront of all. Hope you and the family are staying safe and well xx

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to collaredmichael Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s